Skip to main content
Jonathan Shay

Jonathan Shay

American doctorWikipedia

Search complete. 6 mentions across 4 episodes found for "Jonathan Shay".

Nov 17, 2026

Lynne WhiteGUEST
28:08
so very passionate around the advocacy for the humans involved in the systems, because when you look at the science around trauma and the studies that are there, it is showing that when we participate in or fail to prevent harm, we carry the consequence within ourselves.
Lynne WhiteGUEST
28:25
And the concept of moral injury, which social psychologist Jonathan Shay discovered in the early 1990s, you know, he was looking at it with combat veterans, that moral injury, which effectively is when you perpetrate or fail to prevent or witness an act contrary to your deepest values, and they have been saying that is the precursor to PTSD and perpetration-induced trauma syndrome, but they were only looking at it in terms of combat veterans.
Lynne WhiteGUEST
28:56
And I got on a call with the researchers, the lead researchers in the world from King's College in London about this.
Lynne WhiteGUEST
29:03
And I said to them, my hypothesis here is that it's not just combat veterans or journalists that are suffering from moral injury or moral distress.
Matthew WilkinsonHOST
3:48
Sure.
Matthew WilkinsonHOST
3:48
Have you talked with Jonathan about that? Because I feel like that's what he talks about all the time is sort of the ontological hierarchy vis-a-vis Dionysius and Maximus.
Timothy PatitsasGUEST
3:59
I think what's happening now is that a lot of people are Basically, a lot of people are working out Plato from first principles for themselves.
Timothy PatitsasGUEST
4:12
I have an entire chapter in my book, in The Ethics of Beauty, on healthy shame.
Timothy PatitsasGUEST
4:31
I think a lot of people are just coming independently.
Timothy PatitsasGUEST
4:35
to rediscover these things.
Timothy PatitsasGUEST
4:36
And then, you know, I have talked with Jonathan before, but really the strong idea of, you know, hierarchy is really his fractal order that I owe that explicitly to my former student, Georgia Williams.
Timothy PatitsasGUEST
4:48
Yeah, she has a paper out you can find somewhere in academia about that.
TristanHOST
36:07
And...
TristanHOST
36:08
I also want to comment that in many ways, it's the complete opposite of what we read with Jonathan Shay in for book five, spending all that time thinking about Odysseus as a veteran.
TristanHOST
36:22
And then Arf comes along and says, well, actually Odysseus is creating this new identity where he's this survival or survivor of these magical journeys.
TristanHOST
36:31
And it's not so much about him as a veteran.
Adam MagersGUEST
40:42
But there's a great book called Trauma in the Soul by a Jungian analyst named Donald Calshed where he talks about that exact imagery as being symbolic of a trauma survivor overcoming the things that threaten them and keep them feeling in danger.
Adam MagersGUEST
40:58
And in Jonathan Shay's interpretation of that scene of the Odyssey, he says this stands for veterans and their violent tendencies and their desire to want to kill civilians.
Adam MagersGUEST
41:08
And I read that and I thought, see, this is the problem.
Adam MagersGUEST
41:11
You know, like we we live in this world where many people look at veterans and they see us as these toxic, violent people.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.