
James W. Lewis
63
MENTIONS
21
EPISODES
18
PODCASTS
Search complete. 63 mentions across 21 episodes found for "James W. Lewis".
Sep 30, 2026
156. The Tylenol Murders – Part 3
J
1:21Julia CowleyHOST
We also have a Facebook fan page called Unsubs, and it was created by fans for fans of the consult where listeners can discuss our episodes and other true crime topics.
J
1:36Julia CowleyHOST
Last time we were in the middle of talking about James Lewis, who was one of the two main suspects who had been developed in this case.
J
1:45Julia CowleyHOST
And I want to jump right back into that discussion.
J
1:48Julia CowleyHOST
So as a reminder, James Lewis became a main suspect in after writing an extortion letter to Johnson & Johnson requesting that $1 million be wired to an account if, quote, you want to stop the killing, end quote.
A
2:08Angela SerserPANELIST
I did want to say something about the extortion letter.
A
2:12Angela SerserPANELIST
There was an investigator that was talking about one of the reasons that they believe that Lewis was actually responsible for the poisonings is because some of the language in the letter had to be from somebody that was knowledgeable about it.
7 MINS LATER
B
9:49Bob DrewPANELIST
If they bought this at all, it would at least give this guy a really hard time and a scary time.
B
9:57Bob DrewPANELIST
And that seems very much...
True Crime Time For September 29, 2026 | A New Lead in the Tylenol Murders, a Deadly McDonald's Run & Family Matters
W
7:09Woody OvertonHOST
Well, technically, this case has never been solved.
W
7:13Woody OvertonHOST
The James Lewis, who is the only person convicted in connection with Tylenol killings, died in 2023.
W
7:22Woody OvertonHOST
And this is according to ABC News.
W
7:25Woody OvertonHOST
so i'll tell you about mr james lewis the back to chicago and they said this is when when august 4th of 2023 the i team let's see if i can play this
W
7:45Woody OvertonHOST
she's got energy to do things that she wasn't doing before the umbrella is used to
S
7:49speaker_2SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Tonight, our ABC7 Eye team has learned the cause of death for the prime suspect in the 1982 Tylenol murders.
S
7:56speaker_2SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
An autopsy from the Massachusetts Chief Medical Examiner tonight shows James Lewis died from a pulmonary embolism.
S
8:03speaker_2SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Lewis was the only convicted Tylenol criminal.
Journal Gazette - September 28, 2026
S
51:11ShelleyHOST
It did not say whether they consider Petuski a suspect.
S
51:15ShelleyHOST
Investigators long believed a man named James Lewis was responsible for the killings, though he was never charged.
S
51:22ShelleyHOST
Lewis died in 2023 after serving more than 12 years in prison for sending an extortion note to Johnson & Johnson, the drugs manufacturer at the time, demanding $1 million to stop the killing.
S
51:36ShelleyHOST
When Lewis was arrested in 1982, he gave investigators a detailed account of how the killer might have operated.
Solved Cold Cases With The Most Insane Twists Ever
A
24:08AnthonyHOST
Then on October 1st, an extortion letter arrived demanding $1 million.
A
24:13AnthonyHOST
The letter was traced to James William Lewis, and a nationwide manhunt ended with his arrest in New York City.
A
24:20AnthonyHOST
Lewis had a complicated history.
A
24:22AnthonyHOST
He had worked as an accountant in the 1970s and had previously been charged in connection with the death of a client.
MINI TRUE CRIME ROUNDUP: A new chapter in the Tylenol murder mystery
S
37:58Scott ParksSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Oh, pardon me.
S
37:58Scott ParksSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
The prime suspect was named as James Lewis because he was demanding $1 million to stop the killing.
D
38:05Dana WrightSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Yeah, he was an extortionist, though, Sam.
D
38:07Dana WrightSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
I think a lot of people believe he was an extortionist, not maybe the mastermind behind it.
TRUE CRIME ROUNDUP: A new chapter in the Tylenol poisonings saga, evidence debunked in murder case, a 'House of Horrors' update and more
S
36:57Sam StevieSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Oh, pardon me.
S
36:57Sam StevieSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
The prime suspect was named as James Lewis because he was demanding $1 million to stop the killing.
D
37:04Dana WrightSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Yeah, he was an extortionist, though, Sam.
D
37:06Dana WrightSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
I think a lot of people believe he was an extortionist, not maybe the mastermind behind it.
8PM ET 09/24/2026 Newscast
L
3:19Lisa LuceroHOST
At least seven people were killed in the Tylenol poisonings in the Chicago area.
L
3:23Lisa LuceroHOST
James Lewis, the longtime leading suspect, was convicted of extortion after demanding a million dollars from the drug company.
L
3:29Lisa LuceroHOST
He was never charged for the killings and died in twenty twenty-three.
L
3:33Lisa LuceroHOST
Italy's government has passed a decree introduced this week by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni to place a limit on the number of students in each school classroom who have only limited Italian, Italian language skills, and has also voted to ban face coverings, Islamic veils in schools.
Freedom Friday: Dolly's Family Crisis
B
26:38Brad StaggsHOST
Come on.
B
26:39Brad StaggsHOST
Investigators had long focused on James Lewis, I remember that too, who was suspected of the killings, but he was never charged.
B
26:45Brad StaggsHOST
And he died in 23 after serving more than 12 years in prison, not for the murders.
B
26:51Brad StaggsHOST
He was convicted of extortion after sending a note to Johnson and Johnson demanding a million dollars to stop the killing.
Necro Overtime: A Tylenol Tease & A Frosty Breakup
D
9:27DaveHOST
That feels nice.
D
9:30DaveHOST
Margolis and other top figures in the investigation of the seven Tylenol cyanide killings have long focused on the only person who was actually brought to justice in the poisoning murder cases, James Lewis, that very strange man that we talked about.
D
9:45DaveHOST
It was Lewis who was convicted of federal extortion charges after sending a million-dollar demand letter to Tylenol manufacturer Johnson & Johnson to, quote, stop the killings.
I
9:55IanHOST
That dude is so wild.
How a Serial Killer Planted Invisible Death Traps in Grocery Stores
B
22:26BrewHOST
Why? He recognized him, but not as Robert Richardson.
B
22:30BrewHOST
He knew him as James Lewis, a man with a shady resume to say the least.
B
22:35BrewHOST
This sergeant, along with two detectives, hopped on a plane to Chicago, brought their knowledge to the Tylenol task force, and officially connected the dots.
B
22:43BrewHOST
Robert Richardson and James Lewis were one and the same.
B
22:47BrewHOST
Investigators began running a thorough background check on Lewis, uncovering some gruesome facts.
B
22:52BrewHOST
His first run-in with the law occurred four years before the Tylenol murders, when he was suspected of killing and dismembering Raymond West, a man for whom Lewis had worked as an accountant.
B
24:28BrewHOST
He's hunched over a reference book about major newspaper addresses.
B
24:31BrewHOST
Something clicks, and she calls the FBI.
11 more episodes mention James W. Lewis.
Create an account to see the whole feed, search across every transcript, and follow the entities you care about.