Hung jury
210
MENTIONS
81
EPISODES
65
PODCASTS
Search complete. 210 mentions across 81 episodes found for "Hung jury".
Sep 21, 2026
Christopher SmithermanGUEST
So she killed all three of her children while her husband was out and about.
Christopher SmithermanGUEST
And so now we have this trial, and it ended in a hung jury, 11-1.
Christopher SmithermanGUEST
Now, the one person who held out, people didn't know what the person's race was until recently.
Christopher SmithermanGUEST
And so this person is African-American, African-American male, and an African and a male Republican.
Tony BruschiHOST
And I just don't know that you're going to get there with some.
Tony BruschiHOST
And that's, again, that's exactly why if we did this again, if we do this again, we're going to end up exactly where you said, Bob, with another hung jury, because you just can't fix the thinking in some.
Bob MottaGUEST
Well, I have an answer to that.
Bob MottaGUEST
Yeah.
Nick DargySOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Otherwise, there's nothing wrong with somebody having a completely opposite opinion.
Nick DargySOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
That would be a hung jury.
speaker_4SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
That is our justice system.
speaker_4SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
But he wouldn't engage or couldn't find something to support his view? There was times he
Michael SartainHOST
twice.
Michael SartainHOST
They're a hung jury? Yes, they come to the judge twice.
Michael SartainHOST
There's
Rollo TomassiHOST
also some chick who just got 20
Michael SartainHOST
too.
Rollo TomassiHOST
No, it's going to be a mistrial.
Rollo TomassiHOST
I will tell you right now, it's a hung jury right now, but I will guarantee you it's going to be a mistrial because they've already had some crazy bitch that came in there filming the jurors and trying to influence the jurors.
Rollo TomassiHOST
And I will guarantee you they will pitch for a mistrial at some point.
Tony BruschiHOST
The jury deliberation drama, the Lindsay Clancy trial.
Tony BruschiHOST
It ended in that hung jury, 11 to 1 deadlock.
Tony BruschiHOST
And now the jurors are beginning to break their silence.
Tony BruschiHOST
We're hearing raw, unprecedented accounts from inside the deliberation room, shouting matches, deep psychological trauma.
Tony BrueskiHOST
The jury deliberation drama, the Lindsay Clancy trial.
Tony BrueskiHOST
It ended in that hung jury, 11 to 1 deadlock.
Tony BrueskiHOST
And now the jurors are beginning to break their silence.
Tony BrueskiHOST
We're hearing raw, unprecedented accounts from inside the deliberation room, shouting matches, deep psychological trauma.
Tony BrueskiHOST
And I just don't know that you're going to get there with some.
Tony BrueskiHOST
And that's, again, that's exactly why if we did this again, if we do this again, we're going to end up exactly where you said, Bob, with another hung jury, because you just can't fix the thinking in some.
Tony BrueskiHOST
Well,
Bob MottaGUEST
I have an answer to that.
Tony BruschiHOST
... an opinion on, the jury deliberation drama, the, uh, the Lindsey Clancy trial.
Tony BruschiHOST
It ended in that, uh, hung jury, 11 to one deadlock, and now the jurors are beginning to break their silence.
Tony BruschiHOST
We're hearing raw, unprecedented accounts from inside that deliberation room, shouting matches, deep psychological trauma from Patrick Clancy's 911 call, and a lone holdout who allegedly checked out and was scrolling on his phone.
Tony BruschiHOST
We're going to be breaking down the, uh, juror psychology, how 12 everyday people handle secondary trauma, and whether an objective verdict is even possible when postpartum psychosis collides with this unimaginable tragedy.
Amy ShlosbergHOST
And then, of course, they would be not guilty by r- by lack of criminal responsibility, and that would essentially be an acquittal on the ground that the prosecution did not prove the crime beyond a reasonable doubt.
Amy ShlosbergHOST
And then there is the rare occurrence of the hung jury, and this is where the jurors cannot agree unanimously, so there is no verdict.
Amy ShlosbergHOST
Deliberations began on Thursday afternoon, August 27th, 2026.
Amy ShlosbergHOST
On Tuesday, September 1st, the jury sent the judge a note saying that they were unable to reach a unanimous decision.
Amy ShlosbergHOST
Um, Reddington said that 11 jurors had favored a finding of not criminally responsible, and that there was one holdout.
Amy ShlosbergHOST
At first, that was the defense attorney's account of the split, but nobody knew for sure.
Amy ShlosbergHOST
All we knew was that there was a hung jury.
Amy ShlosbergHOST
There was no conviction.
T.L. KearneyHOST
So the question on the table is exactly, Justin, what exactly is a mistrial and what's the legal effect of it? And then you started telling us a little bit about your thoughts on retrying that and how many times can you do that? And is there a limit? So I'd like to hear from you on that.
Justin BaranHOST
Yeah, so mistrial, like you said, in this context, there was a hung jury, meaning they couldn't come to a unanimous decision.
Justin BaranHOST
And I'd mentioned this briefly at the end of the podcast last week that I've had two or three hung juries, both on, I've had one on defense and two on the prosecution side.
Justin BaranHOST
And In my experience, and again, my cases were nowhere near as complicated as Lindsay Clancy or, you know, as large.
Justin BaranHOST
They had, you know, how many witnesses? It went on for how many days? I had two or three day trials.
71 more episodes mention Hung jury.
Create an account to see the whole feed, search across every transcript, and follow the entities you care about.