Skip to main content

Esther Meek

American philosopher and professor

Aug 11, 2026

1:21
Yeah.
1:22
Yeah.
1:22
So when you, you know, any other act of coming to know through all your life, if you're doing it well, it's going to be encounter ask to the end of communion, mutually transformative.
1:37
And I
1:38
think that's way more sophisticated, more interpersonal.
1:43
It's the most sophisticated philosophical act.
1:49
It's the richest thing.
0:00
So Michael Polanyi, the premier scientific discoverer, was the only person who answered my question, which was, how do I know I've made contact with reality? And he was the only person that was even using that lingo.
0:19
And he'd say, oh, by the way, you know you've made contact with reality in a discovery because you have a sense, an unspecifiable sense, an inarticulable sense, a felt body sense of the possibility of indeterminate future manifestations, future possibilities that you cannot name.
0:42
And that's how it's how you know we we humans say sentences like I think i'm on to something.
0:50
Well, that's what he had in mind, right? So you can have this sense that there's possibilities.
0:56
You move to a new town because you think there's possibilities there, right? We choose a friend, somebody to be a friend because we think there's possibilities, you know? So we navigate by this all the time.
1:09
Well, as I was trying to explain that in longing to know, it became more and more apparent to me that it's almost like the possibilities are another person.
0:00
It's helpful to use Polanyi's lingo because he identifies something that nobody else does, and that's the subsidiary.
0:09
So he s- he says all knowing, any cognitive act has a from to structure.
0:18
So things you attend from and things you attend to.
0:23
And so that's subsidiary, focal, and it's always integrative.
0:26
It's never linear.
0:28
And then the thing about the subsidiaries, these are things you rely on, and they're not statements.
speaker_1UNKNOWN
1:29
Mm-hmm.
1:30
But it's not subjective.
0:57
And I can't remember the bottom of the hill, but I can ride a bike.
1:00
But what happens at the top of the hill, I call this point A in Lovington now, is I'm looking at the bike.
1:08
It's totally meaningless, opaque, contraption.
1:13
I'm sure nothing can balance on two points.
1:18
His words mean nothing to me.
1:20
They might as well be another language.
1:22
And then my body is not working out for me either.
1:53
Jupiter,
0:00
If you're a Cartesian by default or anything, it's because your body's a Cartesian.
0:10
In other words, I felt my body as a mindless object containing my mind.
0:21
So Tricia Jones Philadelphia, Back you know to underscore the point the whole thing's got to somehow be blown up and I would would say to that if you're born into modernity and i'm.
0:39
If you've got, I'm loving to know, I talk about a daisy of dichotomies.
0:46
I call it Esther's daisy of dichotomies.
0:48
And I do that because it's a diagnostic to help people see all the opinions they have about knowledge.
18:53
It has to really like come up from the depths, if that makes any sense.
18:58
Yeah, you know, I have a big fat book called Loving to Know sometime when you retire.
19:06
But I reflect on this there.
19:11
I read a book that I'd commend to you if you can find it called I Am My Body.
19:18
and uh toward a theology of embodiment by i never can remember which order her last name is in it's elizabeth moltman wendell or wendell moltman i think it's moltman wendell but uh that was a that was a eye-opening book but one of the things that i remember writing in that book is if you're a cartesian by default or anything it's because your body's a cartesian In other words, I felt my body as a mindless object containing my mind.
20:00
So, uh, back, you know, to underscore the point, the whole thing's got to somehow be blown up.
20:07
And I would say too, that if you're, uh, born into modernity, um, If you've got, I'm loving to know, I talk about a daisy of dichotomies.

18 MINS LATER

38:42
Yeah, go for it.
ZachHOST
7:13
Mm-hmm.
7:13
And, and it's, it's wonder at, at, uh, the, at existence, right? Which is profoundly philosophical.
7:20
But, um, so I wanted to just see if I could, um, go to the bank on this, uh, wonderful claim that Hans Urs von Balthasar is known to have made, which is that the child awakens to consciousness in the gaze of the loving mother.
7:36
And so, uh, and he's talking about how your metaphysics is formed in that.
7:41
Well, I just went to the bank on it.
7:43
I've got these different chapters in The Mother's Smile about how we are formed philosophically in that natal welcome.
7:51
So our sense of our own existence, how we go about knowing, how we s- how we're involved with reality, what reality is like, our regard for the other, and, um, the face of God.

32 MINS LATER

ZachHOST
39:38
Do you have kind of any projects you're currently working on that you might like to share about here? Any kind of further un- unfoldings of, of what you're doing?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.