Skip to main content
Daron R. Shaw

Daron R. Shaw

Political scientist

Nov 13, 2026

13:32
Why was that? And what should we learn from differential partisan turnout?
13:37
Sure.
13:37
I think just to briefly summarize the argument that John Petrosik and I made in our book, The Turnout Myth, there's a longstanding argument, and it's not just an American argument.
13:49
It's actually an argument you hear in comparative politics and across the globe that if turnout rises, it inherently helps left-leaning parties.
13:58
And the argument is basically that rooted in the observation that left-leaning voters tend to be more likely to be kind of peripheral voters.
14:07
So if you look at the profile of non-voters, not only in the United States, but in other countries, they sort of look like Democrats or social Democrats or left of center partisans.
14:16
And that's true, that is absolutely true.

17 MINS LATER

31:05
So evaluate the polls this year and what happened.
1:15
So can you take us like from Friday before the election to, you know, polls closing and tell us what information you get and when and how you weighed it and all of that good stuff?
1:28
Sure.
1:28
And I'll try to be brief and not lapse into, you know, professor talk.
1:33
First of all, your audience should know that there's a media consortium that sponsors this data collection process.
1:40
And so it's Associated Press with ABC, CBS, NBC, Fox News, CNN.
1:46
MS Now is a new partner in addition to NBC since they've split up.
1:51
And we at Fox, after the 2016 election, went off with AP and built a fairly extensive redesign of election polling.

5 MINS LATER

7:12
What happened from, let's say, 8 o'clock on?
8:22
Darren, are Latinos officially like the most coveted group, maybe aside from suburban women? I mean, they seem like this bellwether group now that you, you know, it could really put you over the top or really hold you back.
8:33
I think they're one.
8:34
You know, I do think, you know, suburban women, rural voters, you know, we can kind of go down the list.
8:42
Independence sort of people who say they're ideologically slightly conservative.
8:47
There are a number of groups that anybody is doing these sort of sophisticated demographic analyses, cluster analyses in marketing terms.
8:54
They could point to everybody seems to think they've got the group that explains the universe.
8:58
But I like to keep this stuff pretty simple.

6 MINS LATER

15:08
Do you think that's accurate, his take?
21:09
So what should voters there keep on their radar?
21:12
Roughly speaking, everybody probably remembers, not that distant, I suppose, but politics moves so fast these days, that Republicans had a mid-decade redistricting in Texas.
21:22
They had a mild gerrymander after the 2020 census.
21:25
Mild meaning that, you know, if you look at seats to votes, Kamala Harris won roughly 43% of the vote in Texas in 2024.
21:32
The redistricting after 2020 gave Democrats about 33 percent of the districts.
21:37
Right.
21:37
So that's that 43 to 33 is the, you know, the extent of the partisan gerrymander.
26:08
How do you look at polling numbers a week out? And should they be fully trusted? What kind of grain of salt are we taking with that?
Carol Roth
Carol RothCORRESPONDENT
17:13
Darren Shaw is a Republican pollster and a member of the Fox News Decision Desk.
17:17
Or conditions or, you know, vibes, actually.
17:20
Now, we don't, I guess maybe we don't use that term, uh, very often in the past, but it's something that kinda captures what we've known about for a long time, and that is presidential approval and appraisals of the economy have a strong correlation with outcomes in midterm elections, especially the first midterm, uh, for an incumbent president.
17:38
This is obviously the second midterm, but they're not consecutive terms, so we, we kinda treat Trump too almost like, uh, you know, the first administration for a, for a new president.
17:49
And the expectation is that they'll lose seats.
17:52
The magnitude of the loss tends to be conditioned by whether or not the economy, uh, y- you know, is jump-started by the new president, whether or not the, the president communicates his agenda well and kinda has a extended honeymoon period.
18:04
None of that seems to be in play here.
Carol Roth
Carol RothCORRESPONDENT
21:47
Hmm.

Unknown podcast

Lindsey Graham’s Decades Of Influence On American Foreign Policy

Jul 13 · 34m

20:14
What impact does it have on the country, in your view, when many people don't understand how government functions and the role of citizens in it?
20:24
My sense is that parents and K through 12 educators traditionally have been the dominant sources of information about citizenry and about civics.
20:34
But it seems that both at the level of the family, because we know, we've seen the divorce statistics, the birth rate statistics issues that face the country right now, that it doesn't seem to be the case that the sort of traditional two-parent family where, you know, people would sit around the dinner table at, you know, five o'clock every day and talk about what's going on, not only in their lives, but in the world.
20:59
That seems to be more of a, you know, kind of a historical artifact now than maybe it used to be.
21:04
And then within the K-12 schools, other things, either that civics education is missing or it's crowded out by, well, here's some competing views of citizenship or some other norms and notions that we want you to recognize, right? So what does that mean? It means when These kids get to college, to my age, or they begin to be asked to participate in civic life in the united states they're looking around for cues because they don't have a baseline of knowledge and that puts an emphasis on the media on social media on their peer network which can also be an online network on sources of information that traditionally we don't consider as credible so outside the kind of dominant news sources that used to exist in the united states they're kind of putting it together as best they can and i think that heightens the role of information sources and elites that you and I might say, that's probably not the best place for them to get information on these things.
22:16
Do you think this structural lack of civics knowledge is what gives these kinds of impossible promises, you know, their weight and their staying power?
22:26
You know, I'd be a little cagey here in the sense that I think we don't want to be a historical.
22:32
I don't think we want to look over back across the scope of American history and think that as much as we respect what previous generations have done, that they came to the table with a deep and abiding sense of the law and constitutionality.
speaker_14UNKNOWN
22:48
Do you think this structural lack of civics knowledge is what gives these kinds of impossible promises, you know, their, their weight and their staying power?
22:58
You know, I'd, I'd be a little cagey here in the sense that I, I think we don't wanna be ahistorical.
23:04
I, I don't think we want to look over, back across the scope of American history and think that, you know, as much as we respect what, uh, previous generations have done, that they came to the table with a deep and abiding sense of the law and constitutionality.
23:18
Um, I do think it was sort of taught at a slightly higher, more consistent level than it has been.
23:24
But are we now in an era where, you know, charismatic demagogues, you know, can take advantage of a citizenry that's not quite as sharp when it comes to understanding the law and understanding the Constitution? I think it's a real possibility.
23:39
I, I'm not...
23:40
I think it's two things coupled, though.

5 MINS LATER

speaker_12UNKNOWN
29:05
What's on your mind?

Unknown podcast

From Washington: A Nation Divided Ahead of America's 250th

Jun 14 · 31m

5:22
Has that been linearly downward or has there been some sudden drop in recent years?
5:28
I think, and you might have anticipated this, the Trump years.
5:33
And I say that advisedly because a lot of people kind of want to lay this at the doorstep of the current president, this sort of divide that we see in the country.
5:45
But it's actually, I think it's important for people to bear in mind that what Trump represents is a coalitional shift.
5:54
in the political parties.
5:55
And in the parlance of political science, we often talk about a realignment.
6:00
And what Trump has done is essentially mobilized a lot of disaffected, lower status people, many of whom were sort of dislocated economically with the financial collapse in 08 and 09.
8:30
Well, first of all, do you just ask people if they're MAGA, whatever their definition of that is?
5:33
Now, this less positive sentiment about the USA in general and saying, "Well, I'd rather live somewhere else," has that been linearly downward, or has there been some sudden drop in recent years?
5:43
I think, and, and you might have an- anticipated this, um, the Trump years, and, and I think it's...
5:50
I, I say that advisedly because, um, a lot of people kind of wanna lay this at the, at, at the doorstep of, of the current president, this sort of divide that we see in the country.
6:00
Um, but, but it's actually...
6:02
I, I think it's important for people to bear in mind that what, what Trump represents is a coalitional shift Uh, in the political parties.
6:10
And in the parlance of political science, we often talk about a realignment.
6:14
Um, and what Trump has done is, is essentially mobilize a lot of, uh, disaffected lower status people, many of whom were, were sort of dislocated economically with the financial collapse in '08 and '09.

9 MINS LATER

14:59
... and gas is somehow $3.10 a gallon.
speaker_2UNKNOWN
3:20
Darren Shaw is a professor of government at the University of Texas at Austin and a member of the Fox News Decision Desk.
3:26
Ted Cruz, incumbent, spent a ton of money prior to the, the initial primary trying to increase the negatives amongst Republicans for Paxton.
3:35
Paxton, with all the baggage he brings to the table, and, uh, I know your, your listeners probably know that, uh, he's, he's had all sorts of allegations about corruption and malfeasance.
3:45
He was impeached, although not convicted by the Texas Senate.
3:48
But his numbers, his favorabilities amongst Republican voters have been remarkably high.
3:52
Uh, they're, they're higher than Cruz, um, who's really had kind of no major issues or problems in the Senate or in his campaigns.
4:00
So Cruz spent a ton of money trying to negatively define Paxton, and Cruz did have the edge in that race, which was actually kind of a surprise to people who were following polling pretty closely in advance of that.

8 MINS LATER

speaker_2UNKNOWN
11:43
[chuckles]

Unknown podcast

Lone Star Showdown: Cornyn vs. The MAGA Endorsement

May 26 · 34m

2:25
Darren Schultz is a professor of government at the University of Texas at Austin and a member of the Fox News Decision Desk.
2:30
John Cornyn, the incumbent, spent a ton of money prior to the, the initial primary trying to increase the negatives amongst Republicans for Paxton.
2:40
Paxton, with all the baggage he brings to the table, and I know your, your listeners probably know that, uh, he's, he's had all sorts of allegations about corruption and malfeasance.
2:49
He was impeached, although not convicted by the Texas Senate.
2:53
But his numbers and his favorabilities amongst Republican voters have been remarkably high.
2:57
Uh, they're, they're higher than Cornyn's, um, who's really had kinda no major issues or problems in the Senate or in his campaigns.
3:05
So Cornyn spent a ton of money trying to negatively define Paxton.

7 MINS LATER

10:28
Um, have these races been unique to Texas, or i- is it sort of the national conversation about who's more progressive?
19:08
And you might have the same thing for Democrats going to the Republican primary and voting for Paxton because they think he might be easier to beat in November, correct?
19:15
[laughs] Yes, I think-- I'll, I'll use a line here, uh, with some trepidation, but it's-- Several people I've, I've talked to in Texas have said that the race we want is Cornyn versus Talarico, um, two sort of y- you know, kinda more traditional representatives of the Republican and Democratic sides.
19:32
Um, the race that we deserve is Crockett versus Paxton [laughs], which I, I think is kind of a funny line.
19:37
Um, I think the one the Democrats really would like is Paxton-Talarico, you know? That, uh, you know, I say Democrats, I mean establishment Democrats who think that if that's the match-up, then Texas joins Alaska, Maine, North Carolina, and Ohio as potential pickups for the Democrats, right? Remember, they need four to flip the Senate.
19:58
There are only four races that are even marginally competitive right now.
20:02
Um, if Texas-- If they get the match-up they want in Texas, it, it could be a fifth, which opens the door slightly to a, a, a Democratic takeover.
20:34
He has resisted calls to drop out and to resign, but the timing of this has put him in a bullseye, in a spotlight that he didn't expect, I would imagine.
20:44
Yes.

Unknown podcast

How Long Could 'Operation Epic Fury' Last?

Mar 3 · 32m

19:08
And you might have the same thing for Democrats going to the Republican primary and voting for Paxton because they think he might be easier to beat in November, correct?
19:15
[laughs] Yes, I think-- I'll, I'll use a line here, uh, with some trepidation, but it's-- Several people I've, I've talked to in Texas have said that the race we want is Cornyn versus Talarico, um, two sort of y- you know, kinda more traditional representatives of the Republican and Democratic sides.
19:32
Um, the race that we deserve is Crockett versus Paxton [laughs], which I, I think is kind of a funny line.
19:37
Um, I think the one the Democrats really would like is Paxton-Talarico, you know? That, uh, you know, I say Democrats, I mean establishment Democrats who think that if that's the match-up, then Texas joins Alaska, Maine, North Carolina, and Ohio as potential pickups for the Democrats, right? Remember, they need four to flip the Senate.
19:58
There are only four races that are even marginally competitive right now.
20:02
Um, if Texas-- If they get the match-up they want in Texas, it, it could be a fifth, which opens the door slightly to a, a, a Democratic takeover.
20:34
He has resisted calls to drop out and to resign, but the timing of this has put him in a bullseye, in a spotlight that he didn't expect, I would imagine.
20:44
Yes.
2:47
If that seems counterintuitive, well, Darren Shaw, a Republican pollster who helps conduct the Fox News poll with Democrat colleague Chris Anderson, explains border security and immigration are viewed distinctly by voters.
3:02
When I came to Texas, and then we started doing the Texas poll and the University of Texas poll, we noted [chuckles] pretty early on two things.
3:08
First, border security and immigration, if you combine the, the mentions, dominated the state's most important issue question, and that's been true for, gosh, I- I would say 20 years.
3:19
The combined responses for border security and immigration are always at the top, so the salience is really high.
3:24
However, if the question is border laws, having a border policy, committing resources and structures to enforce that border policy, people want that, and they tend to trust Republicans to follow through on that issue.
3:40
If the question, on the other hand, is, "Can you round up..." At this point, it's more than this, but for years it was about 11 million undocumented workers, " ...
3:47
and, uh, effectively find them and get them out of the country?" People didn't think that was realistic.

13 MINS LATER

16:27
... that's a big deficit.
3:54
Mm-hmm.
3:54
... because they no longer use it as an issue.
3:56
Uh, but there is something to, uh, the argument that in, y- you know, 2022 and 2024, the Republicans were, were s- seen as being the, you know, the better party, better able to handle kind of the core concerns that Americans had.
4:11
So, inflation prices, border security and immigration, and crime and public safety.
4:17
And the Democrats were trying to put together a, you know, cobble together a hodgepodge of smaller issues that might, uh, mobilize their voters or get them to parody with the Republicans.
4:26
So it was, it was abortion, it was, uh, you know, sort of social issues, and, and these sorts of things.
4:32
And they did a pretty good job of micro-targeting smaller issues and being competitive.
9:12
Does that factor into the healthcare issue, or is there something a little bit bigger there or can you see this story kind of falling off by the time we get to November?
16:06
What's the difference here? Why would they be so different? Eight points in the Fox poll among likely voters and tied in that one.
16:13
So it's, it's certainly possible that it's just a matter of statistical differences, just random error associated with sampling.
16:20
And then there's also a question of how do you screen for likely voters? When we run the Fox poll, we don't screen for likely voters until we get into the fall campaign.
16:29
So we're not gonna run summer polling, for instance, next year in '26 and have a, uh, a likely voter screen in April because part of our likely voter screen involves the attitudes of voters, so their self-expressed willingness to say they're going to vote, their interest in the election.
16:45
All these are variables that we can use to model those who we think are going to actually show up on Election Day, as well as past vote history.
16:53
Well, what about people who, you know, have just come of age? They have no vote history.
16:58
What about people who have not voted in the past too but are suddenly fired up about this race and tell you, "I'm dead solid.

5 MINS LATER

22:05
A recent Fox News poll gave Momdani a 45-31 lead over Cuomo with Republican Curtis Sliwa far back at just 13%.
21:19
Fox News decision desk and polling team member and University of Texas at Austin professor Daron Shaw joined Jessica Rosenthal on the Fox News Rundown this week to discuss.
21:29
I think you can, uh, think of this as, uh, an American phenomenon and an international phenomenon.
21:34
And there's been a lot of, uh, talk in, in response to President Trump's statements about the relative frequency of, uh, mail-in voting, uh, internationally.
21:43
Lots of corrections and fact checks coming in.
21:45
But I pulled the data from the International Institute for Democracy and Election Assistance.
21:50
This is like, it, it's, it's a pretty, uh, authoritarian, authoritarian (laughs).
21:56
Authoritative, um, you know, kind of, uh, source on these sorts of data.

12 MINS LATER

Jessica Rosenthal
Jessica RosenthalCORRESPONDENT
33:48
Hmm.
17:09
Daron Shaw is a member of the Fox News Decision Desk and polling team and University of Texas at Austin professor.
17:15
Lots of corrections and fact checks coming in, but I pulled the data from the International Institute for Democracy and Election Assistance.
17:23
It's a pretty authoritative source on these sorts of data.
17:27
And, and most recently, out of 204 countries, we've got 12 that allow all of their voters to vote by mail, and then another 22 allow some of their voters to vote by mail.
17:38
So that, that ends up being about, what is that? 20...
17:41
No, about 17%.
17:43
17% of voters across the world, you know, reside in a country where they can vote by mail.

8 MINS LATER

25:35
... you are limiting the possibility for something to go wrong.
25:56
i know josh
25:57
i mean i just wonder how you know josh has his numbers on latinos but i i don't think you're crazy i think the A couple of quick points.
26:04
The first is, you know, my mind always goes partly because they're both Republicans, but to Reagan.
26:10
But Reagan embodied a broader ideology that started, you know, at least manifestly with Goldwater in 1964.
26:18
And it was the ascendance of this ideology such that Reagan's interpretation of that ideology wasn't as important as the ideology.
26:26
He was a crisp and effective articulator of that ideology.
26:29
But But if Reagan had taken positions – and we can make an argument with respect to, well, he didn't really cut government spending.

23 MINS LATER

49:44
Darren, what's your – What's your pop here?
18:34
Darren Shaw is a politics professor at the University of Texas at Austin and member of the Fox News Decision Team.
18:39
But we know that the public and the voters take their cues from party elites. And what you've seen, uh, in, in kind of a, in a tepid manner in the Israel-Hamas situation and then the, the Ukraine-Russia situation, is party leaders tentatively kind of staking out more or less aggressive, uh, positions. Uh, but right now, we've got a, a, a pretty clear divide. Uh, Vance and Trump, uh, I probably should say it the other way around, although (laughs) you know, I think those of us who watched the news conference last, or you know, the press conference last week, uh, might put Vance at the forefront of this particular movement. Uh, they've staked out a very, uh, realpolitik, harkening back to Kissinger, uh, approach towards foreign policy. They, they look like they're trying to triangulate, uh, to, to get a deal with the Russians, to put pressure on the Chinese. They've got a, it's kind of very complex foreign policy, but it's, it's knitted together this America first and American interest, uh, perspective. And I think Democrats who honestly, and I don't mean this pejoratively, but their guiding principle seems to be to oppose Trump. Um, they seem to have picked up on the, well, you know, Ukraine is, is for everybody and American commitment to human rights and, um, and, and the defense of the alliance must take precedence, so they've kind of moved in the opposite direction. Um, and I, I think the numbers are gonna reflect that. Um, I, it's, foreign policy is one place where there's not as significant a divide in approval between Republicans and Democrats. Overall, by the way, just to put a number to it, Trump is at plus 74 approve, disapprove with Republicans. He's at minus 83 with Democrats. So there is no honeymoon. Like polarization occurred the second Trump was elected and was already in place by the time he, he was inaugurated. The key number for me, Tess, is with independents. And with independents-

5 MINS LATER

25:32
... Nancy Pelosi are advising, you know, no spectacular shows of, of disagreement. Um, where, where are the American people, um, I guess, when it comes to Democrats as we, I guess, wait to see what Elissa Slotkin has to say, a, a, a Democrat who won a Senate seat in a state that went red?
25:50
Yeah. I, I, I guess two broad observations, and, and I don't think Democrats would necessarily agree with- disagree with either of these. Uh, the first is, y- you know, we asked in our December Fox poll about, uh, resistance. We asked about, um, you know, Republicans cramming stuff down the Democrats' throats, and there wasn't much appetite for that. On the other hand, there was even less appetite for opposing the president and congressional proposals. Um, and, and when I say there wasn't much appetite, I wanna say broadly speaking, I, I believe the figure was 79% of Americans said they did not support that approach. And so that's, you know, that en- encompasses, uh, a plurality of Democrats who also said there just- there's not a lot of appetite for that. And that distinguishes 2025 from 2017. Um, there is a sense that, you know, we have serious problems, we need to do something. As opposed to 2017 where it was a shock that Donald Trump was the president. Um, so that, that's one factor. The, the second is that the favorability of Democrats towards their own party, uh, was, was relatively low in 2024 heading into the election. There was about a, a three or four point decline from where it was in 2020. Uh, but it wa- but after the election, it dropped another five points or so. So, Democrats are looking to their leadership, uh, for answers, they're looking for guidance. So you've got this interesting thing where the, the people, you know, the Democratic electorate is looking to the Democratic Party for, um, direction. And the Democratic Party is scared to move because they're not quite sure where their voters are on this. And somebody's gonna have to take a position at some point and, I don't know, maybe Trump resolves this by simply providing an opposition, uh, focal point. Uh, but it might be that the Democrats have to be creative. Um, if you're talking about this new kind of populist dimension, that's not the same thing as waiting for the Republicans to, to propose renewing the tax cuts and saying, "These are tax cuts for the rich and we oppose them." Right? That's the standard playbook. And I think, I do think that's coming. But on these issues of government efficiency and DOGE, what's the smart play for the Democrats? I, I, I actually think the Pelosi notion of kind of keeping your powder dry and figuring out strategically where you support and where you oppose is a really smart strategy. It'll be interesting to see in these hyper-partisan times whether they can actually do that, though.
8:00
Well, I think
8:02
if I'm looking at this from the perspective of the Trump administration, there's four obvious, obvious choices for emphasis.
8:11
Lowering prices of goods and services, strengthening national defense, cutting taxes for taxpayers, individual taxpayers, and then reducing the flow of fentanyl.
8:21
The fifth is immigration, which I think is almost equally obvious, but with an asterisk or with a caveat.
8:29
And when I say obvious, you know, Josh mentioned these, you know, very high priority ratings.
8:34
If you combine high and very high, the top four items, 71% or above are identify them as a high priority or a very high priority.
8:43
So that's, you know, getting prices under control, reducing fentanyl, strengthening defense, cutting taxes.

17 MINS LATER

26:12
Yeah.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.