Carmel

Where you from?

Carmel, New York.

All right, let's see if you know those five Harry Styles songs.

Go for it.

My deep-dive feature in Rolling Stone helped acquit his best friend, Andy Krivak, who'd also been falsely convicted of Josette's murder.

Anthony's false conviction for her murder was the pinch point of his life, but then a second girl vanished in the span of six months in the sleepy little town of Carmel, New York.

Now, Anthony knew that the job wasn't done.

Josette's killer was still out there, and the man who disappeared Robyn as well.

I shared it with my team.

We divvied up its 3,000 pages and promptly went to work.

In the episodes that follow, we'll train our floodlights on a phantom I don't think she realized how dangerous this situation was ... on every move by those Carmel cops They didn't really take the whole thing seriously, I don't think.

They actually thought they were gonna get a confession out of him ... on every lead they followed And that's exactly what made us all think he had something to do with it.

So you grew up where?

In Carmel, New York.

Carmel, New York.

Nice place.

Pretty nice.

It's picket fences and people are just living life.

It's one of the safest communities according to the state to live in.

So you had a relatively happy childhood growing up in Carmel.