Bishul Yisrael

Chores, can you bring it on Chores? Zorea? Okay, I'll skip a few.

Is it, uh, is it, uh, Boire? What do you think about Bishul? You like Makpe Patish? Could it be like- Or Sayish Hillel, which one would you like? It's, there's none.

You don't have to, there's none.

Gosei still, but no.

Because you can go with some very, very silly, uh, conclusions if you take that model to its, uh, ultimate conclusion.

Let's say, for example, it has to be exactly like it was in the Mishkan.

You know, I'm only Chayav for Bishul if I, if, uh, if I cook like the way they cooked in the Mishkan.

When they cooked in the Mishkan, the temperature outside on an average day in the Mishkan in the Midbar was about a hundred degrees or so.

That's a Melacha DeOraisa on Shabbos.

What, what, what Melacha is it? Is it Choresh? Is it Zera'a? Is it Bishul? Is it Hotza'a? Which Melacha is it? So Maitima.

So Amar Rava.

So Rava said that we Tana, don't understand what the Melacha is.

So if you, uh, had to guess which Melacha is the Gemara referring to.

Well, you don't know what it is yet, but everything, you're in the dark here about the Higis and the Shmigis, whatever they are.

But if you had to guess which Melacha it is, I wouldn't guess Bishul.

I wouldn't guess Makneh BePatish.

So Rashi says that, uh, that chalav and-- that, that if it were chelev, then it would be tigun.

Whereas Tosafot says, "Yes, Mefarshim, there are Bishul Assur Torah, the below Bishul Shari, Vayidev Bishul Asur, Afuki Chelev Sheb lav Hachi Asur." How do we know that it's not chelev? Not because it would be called tigun.

No, it's also called Bishul.

But the Torah's telling us, you know what makes this Assur? The fact that it's basar and chalav.

Had it not been basar and chalav, then it would've been-- It's the fact that it's these two ingredients together.

What exactly is that rejection? Is a Machloket Rashi and Tosafot.

Huge Nafkamina.

Right? Rashi's saying that whenever there's a din of Bishul, it means not frying.

Next.

Is that Bishul or is that Havara?

There's no issue whatsoever.

There's not-- There's no Bishul.

Havara, I have to be careful of that.

Mm-hmm.