Beitza
Religious textWikipedia
49
MENTIONS
27
EPISODES
12
PODCASTS
Search complete. 49 mentions across 27 episodes found for "Beitza".
Sep 14, 2026
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
So comes the Gemara and said that, um- With Tanya, we learned in a Braisa, "Acherim Omer Mishum Rabbi Eliezer." Now, the others said in the name of Rabbi Eliezer, the Gemara says that when it says Acherim, that usually refers to Rabbi Meir.
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
So others said in the name of Rabbi Eliezer, "Beitza tochal hi ve'imah," that if you have an egg that was, uh, that was laid on Yom Tov, so you can eat the egg, and you can eat the mother as well.
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
What's-- What, what, what, what are the words mean? L'maayta skhirah, what are we talking about? Im leim b'tanag d'osa d'omet l'achilah.
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
If we're talking about a hen that was designated for eating, I was planning on shechting this hen on Yom Tov, pshita.
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
It means as follows.
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
The Sanya, Acher Omer, there's another Braisa that's almost identical.
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
The Braisa says, "Acher Omer Mishum Rabbi Eliezer, Beitza tochal hi ve'imah ve'afroach ukli poso." If you wanna know what's muktze, you can eat the following.
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
You can eat the egg, and you can eat the hen, and you can eat the, the chicken inside, and you can eat the, the, the shell.
Michael RosensweigHOST
We'll get back to it.
Michael RosensweigHOST
Or there's a Rashi in Beitzah, on Chazah-- you know, in Beitzah.
Michael RosensweigHOST
Rashi would say, "If you burn, if you're making the mitzvah of, uh, of biur, you know, kodshim tmeim or terumat tamei, b'Yom Tov or b'Shabbos, then you violate a melacha, achshave.
Michael RosensweigHOST
And everybody's like, "You can achshave as much as you want, but like which of the lamit ossot melacha are you violating?" So this one, this is another mystery.
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
Anyone bother looking up that Gemara that they're unbiased quoting? The Gemara says, does anyone know what that Gemara is talking about? That's talking about 157 lot in Shabbos? Anyone know? Is that what I'm talking about? I'm talking about the Mechlechis of Rabbi Shimon about Hilchos Moktza.
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
There was a running Mechlechis for many, many times in Shabbos and in Beitza about some of the intricacies of Hilchos Moktza.
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
Rabbi Shimon had a much, much more lenient version of Moktza that Rabbi Huda did.
Zvi SobolofskyHOST
It's not that Rabbi Shimon denied all of Moktza.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Masecha's Meisr is all about what's Gemara Malacha for all the different food items.
Shalom RosnerHOST
But the Gemara in Betza tells us A unique halacha.
Shalom RosnerHOST
What if the levi goes very early and takes his ma'isar rishon? Before there's a chiv of shumah.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Levi's early, he jumps the gun.
Assaf BednarshHOST
So, the, so says the B'yarlacha, no, this isn't the peeling and Kodesh, because Kodesh is Lech HaMasheves, and peeling is not, and obviously this reminds us of the Hilig in Boreh, right? And in Boreh there's a difference between the Yad and the Kli, as we're about to see.
Assaf BednarshHOST
So basically the B'yarlacha is taking that and applying it here, based on the phrase Lech HaMasheves appears later in that Gemara in Beitza, and it's interesting, we don't find that you the old life of your hands.
Assaf BednarshHOST
We don't find that, you know, most malachas, we don't find a hetter that if you just do it in a regular balbatish, non-industrial way, it's mutter.
Assaf BednarshHOST
But, I mean, this is all you have to see, that somehow when it comes to malachas that are involved in eating, when it comes to malachas that are eating, there is a fundamental tension.
Michael RosensweigHOST
Of course, again, the human obligation to commemorate it ends up also accentuating the first, but they're two different ideas.
Michael RosensweigHOST
I'm going to bring it in, but in this new parish, I just saw the other day, so he has a suggestion, he doesn't say, he doesn't quote them, he never quotes the Rambam and Mordecai in any of this, but clearly he's quoting a part of this, And then he has a line, which we need to discuss anyway, that, you know, the Gemara says in Beitza, that, you know, it's significant that we say, on Yom Tov we say, and on Shabbos we say, And the bar explains, because it's kabu v'kaimah misheshes yimei breshes, Shabbos, as opposed to yom tov, which is v'ka desh yisrael v'chazmah.
Michael RosensweigHOST
So the traditional interpretation of that is that, and this way the Ramban understands, is that, what I call a junior partner in Kiddush HaKodesh, in Torah, by virtue of Kiddush HaKodesh, especially the Kiddush HaSazman, so, you know, we have a role, within reason, a junior partnership, not an equal partnership.
Michael RosensweigHOST
partnership, but we have a role in as opposed to Shabbos, which as we know is Kabbalah.
Shalom RosnerHOST
So some say even a Mashu.
Shalom RosnerHOST
But Rashi says here even a Beitza.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Okay.
Shalom RosnerHOST
So the Gemara says if somebody cuts off a piece of flesh from Abraham and Achai.
Hershel SchachterHOST
So what's on the first daf? There are three Masichtos.
Hershel SchachterHOST
Shabbos is on Shabbos, Beitzah is about Yontif, and Moid Katan is the little Chalamid.
Hershel SchachterHOST
Moid Katan is referring to Chalamid, all the dinim of Chalamid.
Hershel SchachterHOST
So the first Rashi on Moid Katan...
Michael RosensweigHOST
Kiva was here.
Michael RosensweigHOST
Right, so in other words, the Gemarim Beitzah on Gimel, on the base, says that, you know, Mux is a Dabr Shei Shalom Atir.
Michael RosensweigHOST
So the Rebbe was very into this idea, you know, which is clear in the Machlokas, but he liked very much the idea.
Michael RosensweigHOST
They only say Dabr Shei Shalom Atir, and Dabr Shei Shalom Atir means what exactly? Ezra? I don't know if having you say it fulfills your day of responsibility.
Michelle Cohen FarberHOST
Okay, now that's the thing.
Michelle Cohen FarberHOST
So the HaMakhloket is, if the Heksher happened before I actually intended it to be eaten by someone who's really going to eat it, like a non-Jew, is that hecher effective or not? Now here we're going to see, ditznan, as it says in the Mishnah, there's a machloket about this, okay? I'm a Rabbi Yehuda, it's a Mishnah in Beitzah.
Michelle Cohen FarberHOST
This is an interesting machloket because in the end they're going to bring Rabbi Akiva versus Rabbi Yehuda, but Rabbi Yehuda is going to say, Rabbi Akiva, you yourself said something against that, Rabbi Akiva is going to change his position.
Michelle Cohen FarberHOST
But the two positions here, even though one is eventually knocked out, but those are the two positions we see in Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Shimon.
17 more episodes mention Beitza.
Create an account to see the whole feed, search across every transcript, and follow the entities you care about.